The Passover Haggadah as Argument, Or Why Is This Text Different from Other Texts?

Zemel, Alan
February 1998
Argumentation;Feb1998, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p57
Academic Journal
In this paper, I demonstrate how the Passover Haggadah exploits certain features of conversational interaction in both the production formats of its texts and in its performance formats (or ways it indicates it should be performed) during the Passover Seder. Some conversational methods used include the use of dispreferred second pair parts which creates an impression that at least part of the Haggadah‘s text resembles a kind of conversational argument. Furthermore, as a recitable text, the Haggadah exploits the use of and changes in footings in a manner reminiscent of how reported speech is used in ordinary conversation to introduce participant roles and virtual participants with their own commitments, orientations and positions which may not represent those of the animators of the recited text. While the Haggadah is not an actual argument in conventional terms, it is a script of ritual texts organized according to a logic similar to the one by which certain kinds of conversational arguments are organized. Participants are able to animate participatory roles and assess the positions, orientations and commitments such roles represent in a manner that rehearses how such positions, orientations and commitments might be accomplished in actual argumentation.


Related Articles

  • Re'haz: An answer in search of a question. Rackman, Joseph R. // Judaism;Summer93, Vol. 42 Issue 3, p313 

    Discusses the reason for washing the hands twice in the re'haz, the second step of the Jewish Passover Haggadah. First washing without a blessing; Blessing for the second washing; Incorporation into the freedom ritual of the Seder; Classic interpretations; Feeling of moral contamination on...

  • The many meanings of Passover.  // New Jersey Jewish News;3/21/2013, Vol. 67 Issue 12, p20 

    The author discusses the interpretations of Jews regarding the Passover.

  • How to stay healthy during Passover. Rueven, Sarah // Washington Jewish Week;3/19/2015, Vol. 51 Issue 12, p44 

    The article discusses tips on how to stay healthy during the Jewish celebrations of Passover along with recipes for Beef and quinoa meatballs and Cinnamon-dusted spaghetti squash kugel with walnuts, dates and apples.

  • In experiencing freedom, the importance of boundaries. Berkowitz, Dasee // Washington Jewish Week;3/7/2013, Vol. 49 Issue 10, p40 

    The article discusses the aspects of boundaries in the Jewish community as they celebrate Passover. The author mentions that the form of the holiday is all about boundaries and that the flow of the seder is all about order. He states that when Jews embrace the boundaries of Jewish commitment...

  • TANTE EVELYN'S SPINACH PIE. Levy, Audrey // Petits Propos Culinaires;Dec2003, Issue 74, p85 

    Recounts the kind of food prepared by Jews during Passover, a Jewish holiday. Recipe for a spinach pie; Significance of matzah pies in Passover holidays; Differences between the Passover celebrations of the Sephardi Jewish community and the Ashkenazi Jewish community.

  • The Number Four in the Passover Haggadah.  // Journal of Progressive Judaism;Nov99, Issue 13, p19 

    Focuses on the importance of number four on Passover Haggadah in Judaism. Role of number four on Pesach festival; Description of Pesach festival; Four major themes of Haggadah.

  • On your table. Housley, Laura Weinger // New Jersey Jewish News;3/25/2010, Vol. 64 Issue 12, p18 

    The article presents the Haggadas which will be on the table of the journal's readers during the Passover in New Jersey.

  • Passover Haggadah supplement 1996. Lerner, Michael // Tikkun;Mar/Apr96, Vol. 11 Issue 2, following p48 

    Offers guidelines for using the Haggadah to celebrate the Passover. Kiddush; Blessing the vegetation of the earth; What to do before reciting the Ten Plagues; After the meal, before opening the door for Elijah.

  • All who are hungry….  // New Jersey Jewish News;4/14/2011, Vol. 65 Issue 15, p18 

    The author reflects on several Jewish groups, include Mazon: A Response to Jewish Hunger, which serve the poor during Passover in the spirit of the Haggada.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics