Beyond physical access: a qualitative analysis into the barriers to policy implementation and service provision experienced by persons with disabilities living in a rural context

Neille, J.; Penn, C.
July 2015
Rural & Remote Health;Jul-Sep2015, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p1
Academic Journal
Introduction: Persons with disabilities make up approximately 15% of the world’s population, with vulnerable communities disproportionately affected by the incidence of disability. Research reflects that persons with disabilities are vulnerable to stigma and discrimination, social isolation, and have physical barriers to accessing support services, all of which serve to perpetuate a sense of uncertainty and vulnerability within their lives. Recently a number of policies and models of intervention have been introduced intended to protect the rights of those affected by disability, yet limited research has been conducted into the lived experiences of persons with disabilities, particularly in rural contexts. This implies that little is known about the impact of the rural context on the lived experience of disability and the ways in which context impacts on the implementation of policies and practices. Methods: The current study employed a qualitative design underpinned by the principles of narrative inquiry and participant observation. Thirty adults with a variety of congenital and acquired disabilities (15 men and 15 women, ranging in age from 19 to 83 years) living in 12 rural communities in the Mpumalanga Province of South Africa were recruited through snowball sampling. Data collection comprised a combination of narrative inquiry and participant observation. Narratives were collected in SiSwati with the assistance of a SiSwati-speaking research mediator and were transcribed and translated into English. Data were analysed inductively according to the principles of thematic analysis. Results: Findings confirmed that the experience of living with a disability in a rural area is associated with discrimination, social exclusion, and isolation and barriers to accessing services, underpinned by numerous context-specific experiences, including mortality rates, exposure to numerous and repeated forms of violence across the lifespan, and corruption and lack of transparency in the implementation of government policies and practices. These experiences are not currently reflected in the literature or in guidelines on the implementations of policies and service provision, and thus have the potential to offer novel insights into the barriers faced by persons with disabilities living in rural areas. Conclusions: The results of this study suggest that barriers to service provision extend beyond physical obstacles, and include a variety of sociocultural and sociopolitical barriers. By failing to take these into account, policies and current models of service provision are only able to provide limited support to persons with disabilities living in rural areas. The findings reveal narrative inquiry to be a powerful and culturally safe tool for exploring lived experience among vulnerable populations and hold significant implications for both practitioners and policy developers. Furthermore, it emerges that one-size-fits-all policies are unable to meet the needs of persons with disabilities living in rural areas. However, the implementation of site-specific needs analyses with the use of flexible and culturally appropriate tools has the potential to redress the discrepancies in policy implementation and can be used to strengthen institutional ties and referral pathways.


Related Articles

  • Social inclusion of people with disabilities: a case from Nepal's decade-long civil war. Lamichhane, Kamal // Scandinavian Journal of Disability Research;Nov2015, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p287 

    This paper discusses the issue of social inclusion of people with disabilities who acquired impairments through Nepal's decade-long insurgency. In-depth qualitative interviews have been conducted with nine individuals. A disparity in government facilities and services was observed, whereby the...

  • An Ethnographic Study of Barriers to Cancer Pain Management and Opioid Availability in India. LeBaron, Virginia; Beck, Susan L.; Maurer, Martha; Black, Fraser; Palat, Gayatri // Oncologist;2014, Vol. 19 Issue 5, p515 

    Background. The world’s global cancer burden disproportionally affects lower income countries, where 80% of patients present with late-stage disease and have limited access to palliative care and effective pain-relieving medications, such as morphine. Consequently, millions die each year...

  • "We'll Get to You When We Get to You": Exploring Potential Contributions of Health Care Staff Behaviors to Patient Perceptions of Discrimination and Satisfaction. Tajeu, Gabriel S.; Cherrington, Andrea L.; Andreae, Lynn; Prince, Candice; Holt, Cheryl L.; Halanych, Jewell H. // American Journal of Public Health;Oct2015, Vol. 105 Issue 10, p2076 

    Objectives. We qualitatively assessed patients' perceptions of discrimination and patient satisfaction in the health care setting specific to interactions with nonphysician health care staff. Methods. We conducted 12 focus-group interviews with African American and European American...

  • Exploring the Potential of Participatory Theatre to Reduce Stigma and Promote Health Equity for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) People in Swaziland and Lesotho. Logie, Carmen H.; Dias, Lisa V.; Jenkinson, Jesse; Newman, Peter A.; MacKenzie, Rachel K.; Mothopeng, Tampose; Madau, Veli; Ranotsi, Amelia; Nhlengethwa, Winnie; Baral, Stefan D. // Health Education & Behavior;Feb2019, Vol. 46 Issue 1, p146 

    Stigma and discrimination affecting lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) people compromise health and human rights and exacerbate the HIV epidemic. Scant research has explored effective LGBT stigma reduction strategies in low- and middle-income countries. We developed and pilot-tested...

  • Barriers to colorectal cancer screening among women in rural central Pennsylvania: Primary care physicians' perspective. Rosenwasser, L. A.; McCall-Hosenfeld, J. S.; Weisman, C. S.; Hillemeier, M. M.; Perry, A. N.; Chuang, C. H. // Rural & Remote Health;Jan-Mar2014, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

    Introduction: Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the third leading cause of death among women in the USA. Rural populations have lower rates of CRC screening than their urban counterparts, and rural women have lower screening rates compared with rural men. The purpose of this qualitative study was to...

  • Healthy Aging in Place: Supporting Rural Seniors' Health Needs. Bacsu, Juanita R.; Jeffery, Bonnie; Johnson, Shanthi; Martz, Diane; Novik, Nuelle; Abonyi, Sylvia // Online Journal of Rural Nursing & Health Care;Fall2012, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p77 

    Purpose: To examine the key determinants that support healthy aging in rural communities. Sample: Forty- two participants aged 65 and older were recruited from two rural communities in Saskatchewan, Canada. Methods: Using an ethnographic methodological approach, data was collected through...

  • Health status and behaviors among adults residing in rural Dominican Republic. Caban-Martinez, A. J.; Halder, G. E.; Tellechea, L.; Fajardo, M.; Kaltman, J.; Anand, J.; Prendes, S.; Penyak, V.; Koganti, D.; Chavoustie, S.; Fleming, L. E. // Rural & Remote Health;Apr-Jun2012, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p1 

    Introduction: The rapidly increasing burden of chronic diseases linked to adequacy of healthcare services and individual health behaviors is a key determinant of global public health. Given demographic aging and the accompanying health transition, chronic diseases in low and middle income...

  • Lung Cancer Treatment Disparities in China: A Question in Need of an Answer. Yang, Lu‐Lu; Zhang, Xu‐Chao; Yang, Xue‐Ning; Yang, Jin‐Ji; Wang, Zhen; Chen, Hua‐Jun; Yan, Hong‐Hong; Xu, Chong‐Rui; Guan, Ji‐Lin; He, Yan‐Yan; Zhong, Wen‐Zhao; An, She‐Juan; Wu, Yi‐Long // Oncologist;Oct2014, Vol. 19 Issue 10, preceding, following p1084 

    Background. Substantial progress has been made in the treatment of malignancies in the People’s Republic of China in recent years.The goal of this study was to identify the extent to which national treatment guidelines are being used to customize patient care in lung cancer and to analyze...

  • Regional disparities in cancer mortality across the rural-urban axis: a case study from north-eastern Greece. Nikolaidis, C; Tentes, I; Lialiaris, T; Constantinidis, TC; Kortsaris, A // Rural & Remote Health;Jul-Sep2015, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p1 

    Introduction: The aim of this study was to identify differences in cancer mortality in north-eastern Greece, to describe potential drivers operating at the population level and to propose practical interventions and mitigation strategies. Methods: Cancer mortality data were collected from local...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics