A hybrid life cycle assessment of public transportation buses with alternative fuel options

Ercan, Tolga; Tatari, Omer
September 2015
International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment;Sep2015, Vol. 20 Issue 9, p1213
Academic Journal
Purpose: Alternative fuel options are gaining popularity in the vehicle market. Adopting alternative fuel options for public transportation compared to passenger vehicles contributes exponentially to reductions in transportation-related environmental impacts. Therefore, this study aims to present total air pollutant emissions and water withdrawal impacts through the lifetime of a transit bus with different fuel options. Methods: In consideration of market share and future development trends, diesel, biodiesel, compressed natural gas (CNG), liquefied natural gas (LNG), hybrid (diesel-electric), and battery electric (BE) transit buses are analyzed with an input-output (IO)-based hybrid life cycle assessment (LCA) model. In order to accommodate the sensitivity of total impacts to fuel economy, three commonly used driving cycles are considered: Manhattan, Central Business District (CBD), and Orange County Transit Authority (OCTA). Fuel economy for each of these driving cycles varies over the year with other impacts, so a normal distribution of fuel economy is developed with a Monte Carlo simulation model for each driving cycle and corresponding fuel type. Results and discussion: Impacts from a solar panel (photovoltaic, PV) charging scenario and different grid mix scenarios are evaluated and compared to the nation's average grid mix impacts from energy generation to accommodate the lifetime electricity needs for the BE transit bus. From these results, it was found that the BE transit bus causes significantly low CO emissions than diesel and other alternative fuel options, while some of the driving cycles of the hybrid-powered transit bus cause comparable emissions to BE transit bus. On the other hand, lifetime water withdrawal impacts of the diesel and hybrid options are more feasible compared to other options, since electricity generation and natural gas manufacturing are both heavily dependent on water withdrawal. In addition, the North American Electricity Reliability Corporation's (NERC) regional electricity grid mix impacts on CO emissions and water withdrawal are presented for the BE transit bus. Conclusions: As an addition of current literature, LCA of alternative fuel options was performed in this paper for transit buses with the consideration of a wide variety of environmental indicators. Although the results indicate that BE and hybrid-powered buses have less environmental emissions, the US's dependency on fossil fuel for electricity generation continues to yield significant lifetime impacts on BE transit bus operation. With respect to water withdrawal impacts, we believe that the adoption of BE transit buses will be faster and more environmentally feasible for some NREC regions than for others.


Related Articles

  • A Review on Knock Phenomena in CNG-Diesel Dual Fuel System. Zulkifli, Fathul Hakim; Fawzi, Mas; Osman, Shahrul Azmir // Applied Mechanics & Materials;2015, Vol. 773-774, p550 

    The compressed natural gas (CNG) - diesel dual fuel engine is discussed through their basic operation and its characteristic. The main problem of running a diesel engine on dual fuel mode with CNG as main fuel is addressed. A brief review of knock phenomena which is widely associated with a dual...

  • Green Trucking: Choices for fleets yet abound. Cullen, David // Fleet Owner Exclusive Insight;3/4/2014, p6 

    The article discusses the highlights of the 2014 Green Truck Summit where speakers talked about alternative fuels for trucking. Topics discussed include the growing range of alternative fuels such as biodiesel and compressed natural gas being offered at public stations, the growing number of...

  • Big Opportunities in Alternative Fuel. Boesel, John // Beverage World;1/15/2014, Vol. 133 Issue 1, p52 

    The article discusses alternative fuels more commonly used by beverage market such as compressed natural gas (CNG), biodiesel and hybrid and all-electric vehicles. It notes that an increasing number of beverage fleets will convert to compressed CNG-operated vehicles due to its low cost and...

  • Mass Transit: Use of Alternative Fuels in Transit Buses: RCED-00-18.  // GAO Reports;12/14/1999, p1 

    To help reduce air pollution in U.S. cities, various alternative fuels have been proposed for use in transit buses, including compressed natural gas, liquified natural gas, methane, ethanol, biodiesel fuel, and propane. GAO found that alternative fuel buses account for a very small, but growing,...

  • Toxicological properties of emission particles from heavy duty engines powered by conventional and bio-based diesel fuels and compressed natural gas. Jalava, Pasi I.; Aakko-Saksa, P„ivi; Murtonen, Timo; Happo, Mikko S.; Markkanen, Ari; Yli-Piril„, Pasi; Hakulinen, Pasi; Hillamo, Risto; M„ki-Paakkanen, Jorma; Salonen, Raimo O.; Jokiniemi, Jorma; Hirvonen, Maija-Riitta // Particle & Fibre Toxicology;2012, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p37 

    Background: One of the major areas for increasing the use of renewable energy is in traffic fuels e.g. bio-based fuels in diesel engines especially in commuter traffic. Exhaust emissions from fossil diesel fuelled engines are known to cause adverse effects on human health, but there is very...

  • Alternative power choices: Fleets can now pick from an ever-growing menu of alternative choices to power their trucks. Cullen, David // Fleet Owner;Apr2010, Vol. 105 Issue 4, p68 

    The article offers information on several alternative fuels for trucks. Natural gas in trucking is used either in compressed (CNG) or liquefied (LNG) form. Biodiesel and ethanol are derived from biomass energy gained from plants and plant-derived materials. Dimethyl ether (DME) is relatively...

  • An Alternative Approach. Abelson, Paul // Concrete Producer;Jan/Feb2011, Vol. 29 Issue 1, p40 

    The article discusses engine technology and alternative fuels important in meeting emission standards. It notes that several engine manufacturers are relying on technologies including selective catalytic reduction (SCR), in-cylinder solution as well as exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) in...

  • DELHI HITS THE GAS. Wright, Martin // Green Futures;Nov/Dec2006, Issue 61, p19 

    The article reports that Delhi, India reduced its air pollution following conversion from diesel fuel to compressed natural gas (CNG) in public buses, rickshaws, and taxis. The 38 percent decline in particulate pollution is also due to enforcement of court orders to shift heavy industry out of...

  • 3 Ways to Become a More Sustainable Cleaning Company.  // ICS: Cleaning Specialist;Apr2014, Vol. 52 Issue 3, p34 

    The article reveals solutions to make a cleaning company become greener. Usage of alternative fuels such as compressed natural gas (CNG) can cut costs by a maximum of 70 percent, as CNG cuts greenhouse emissions by 97 percent and 60 percent of nitrogen oxide emissions. GPS tracking can be used...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics