TITLE

Rethinking refugee law

AUTHOR(S)

Nathwani, N.

PUB. DATE

October 2003

SOURCE

Refugee Survey Quarterly;Oct2003, Vol. 22 Issue 2/3, p477

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

The author states that refugee law faces a serious crisis in Europe. This crisis highlights the need to explain what is the relationship between refugee law and immigration policy. How much immigration do States need to tolerate for moral and practical reasons even if they do not wish any immigration? The legal principle of necessity offers a theoretical basis for refugee law. Necessity explains the conditions under which it would be unfair to fight off unwanted immigrants by deportation and punishment. Necessity explains the conditions under which a restrictive immigration policy is not feasible at a reasonable cost versus desperate individuals. Necessity also overrules a restrictive immigration policy and qualifies as an explanation of the purpose of a fair refugee policy. This book explores the consequences of the theory of necessity for the interpretation of the main concepts of refugee law (persecution, well-founded fear, reasons of persecution, asylum) and concludes that a generous refugee practice can be conceived and justified even if a restrictive immigration policy is a political reality.

ACCESSION #

100184564

 

Related Articles

• Rethinking Refugee Law (Book). Noll, Gregor // Journal of Refugee Studies;Dec2004, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p486 

  Reviews the book "Rethinking Refugee Law," by Niraj Nathwani.

• Unpacking the Passive Refugee. Wolfwood, Theresa // Canadian Dimension;Nov/Dec2006, Vol. 40 Issue 6, p59 

  The article reviews the book "Rethinking Refugees: Beyond States of Emergency," by Peter Nyers.

• Select bibliography.  // Refugee Survey Quarterly;Jan2001, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p191 

  A bibliography highlighting the references to literature relating to the role and activities of the Organization of African Unity (OAU) that were published in 1990 and onwards that were extracted from the Refugee Literature Database (REFLIT) managed by the United Nations High Commissioner for...

• The dilemma of international refugees. Helton, Arthur C. // World & I;Jul93, Vol. 8 Issue 7, p32 

  Discusses the problem of international refugees. United Nation's High Commissioner for Refugees; Refugee protection; International refugee law; Laws enacted by the Russian parliament conferring legal status on forced migrants and refugees; Approaches in responding to refugee emergencies.

• Serbs forcibly enlist refugees to fight.  // Christian Century;8/2/95, Vol. 112 Issue 23, p736 

  Reports on Serbs' forced enlistment of refugees in the ethnic war in Bosnia. Rounding up of male refugees; Violation of the international refugee law.

• Editorial. Gilbert, Geoff // International Journal of Refugee Law;Jan2002, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

  The article offers information on the "International Journal of Refugee Law."

• Seeing Through a Glass, Darkly: The Social Context of `Particular Social Groups' in Lwin... Thomas, John Hans // Brigham Young University Law Review;1999, Vol. 1999 Issue 2, p799 

  Discusses the application of the Refugee Act of 1980 in the Lwin versus INS case. Historical and legislative background on refugee law; Identification of the humanitarian purposes of refugee law; Conclusions.

• REFUGEES: Who, Where, and Why. Gevert, Catherine // Faces;Sep2002, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p8 

  Focuses on the personal, social and economic conditions of refugees. Definition of a refugee by the United Nations; Protection of refugees by international laws; Enumeration of countries with large numbers of refugees. INSET: Refugees..

• A THEORETICAL EXPLANATION OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF CRIMINAL LAW. Troupis, James R. // Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology;Winter1979, Vol. 70 Issue 4, p589 

  Reviews the book "Rethinking Criminal Law," by George P. Fletcher.

• PSYCHIATRY, LAW, AND RESPONSIBILITY. Flew, Antony // Philosophical Quarterly;Oct1985, Vol. 35 Issue 141, p425 

  Reviews the book "Law and Psychiatry: Rethinking the Relationship," by Michael Moore.

Read the Article